OAV Dealer Intelligence
Gary Sells Cars inventory in Madison, WI
OAV.io analyzes millions of vehicle listings using RetailVision™ market data to identify vehicles priced below expected market ranges based on year, make, model, trim (when available), and comparable listings.
OAV helps determine if a vehicle is a good deal by comparing its price to similar listings within its supported comparable range. Sell-through is separate Demand-Verified evidence, not part of the price verdict.
Market snapshot · October 27, 2026
The best priced vehicles at Gary Sells Cars in Madison, WI are listed below their typical market range, based on comparable listings; days-on-lot and Demand-Verified sell-through are shown as separate demand signals. From regularly refreshed market data.
Use this page to
- Compare Gary Sells Cars' prices against the local Madison, WI market.
- Find Gary Sells Cars' lowest-days-on-lot inventory (faster-turning vehicles).
- Track Gary Sells Cars' deal mix (Great Deal / Fair Price / Overpriced) over time.
Top Deals at gary sells cars in Madison, WI Today
Vehicles labeled Great Deal — priced below the comparable-range floor by at least OAV's minimum-gap margin, per OAV's price-to-market analysis of comparable listings. Days-on-lot velocity is a separate demand signal, not part of the verdict.
154 total vehicles listed · 154 used
Request availability and out-the-door price
OAV will route your inquiry to Gary Sells Cars for current availability and an out-the-door price quote (taxes, fees, add-ons included). Choose from 154 vehicles in inventory.
OAV routes your inquiry; pricing, taxes, fees, and availability come from the dealer.
Are you this dealer? Claim this page (free) or sign in.
Best-priced vehicles at Gary Sells Cars
OAV found 154 active listings for Gary Sells Cars in Madison, WI. The strongest deal signals are based on price-to-market range and comparable listings; days-on-lot and Demand-Verified sell-through are shown as separate demand signals, not ranking inputs.
Top deals on this page are vehicles rated Great Deal — priced below the comparable-range floor by at least OAV's minimum-gap margin; days-on-lot and Demand-Verified sell-through appear alongside as separate demand context, never as part of the verdict.
Powered by OAV's patented vehicle market standardization technology (U.S. Patent No. 12,236,477).
Top deal signals
Vehicles at this dealer with the strongest below-market signal based on OAV's price-to-market analysis. Ranked by deal strength.
| Vehicle | Price | Expected Market Range | PTM Gap | DOL | Why it stands out |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2021 Toyota Tacoma | $40,000 | $41,888 – $42,301 | 4.5% below | 9 days | Priced 4.5% below OAV's expected market range, 9 days listed. |
Compared against similar comparable listings.
According to RetailVision™ data, OAV is currently analyzing approximately 200 vehicles in this dealer's inventory in Madison, WI.
Used Inventory
154 used vehicles · evidence-backed Price-to-Market analysis
Vehicles Listed
154
Average Price
$31,826
Price Range
$9,000–$77,998
Avg Days on Lot
14
Deal Mix· 100 of 154 shown
Great Dealsⓘ
1
1.0% of 100 shown
Fair Priceⓘ
35
35.0% of 100 shown
Overpricedⓘ
0
0.0% of 100 shown
Unscoredⓘ
64
64.0% of 100 shown
Current Inventory (100 of 154)
Sorted by deal quality. Each listing rated by OAV's Price-to-Market analysis.
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2021 Toyota Tacoma
Madison, WI
Market: $41,888 – $42,301
Comparison: 18 similar vehicles
Competitively priced ~5% below the typical range compared to similar vehicles · 9 days listed (based on current market benchmarks)
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2016 Honda CR-V
Madison, WI
Market: $6,999 – $19,590
Comparison: 73 similar vehicles
Fairly priced — in line with the typical market range for similar vehicles · 18 days listed (based on current market benchmarks)
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2024 Toyota RAV4
Madison, WI
Market: $27,843 – $34,394
Comparison: 73 similar vehicles
Fairly priced — in line with the typical market range for similar vehicles · 4 days listed (based on current market benchmarks)
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2021 Toyota Corolla
Madison, WI
Market: $11,465 – $20,176
Comparison: 70 similar vehicles
Fairly priced — in line with the typical market range for similar vehicles · 10 days listed (based on current market benchmarks)
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2019 Toyota Tacoma
Madison, WI
Market: $25,899 – $38,278
Comparison: 70 similar vehicles
Fairly priced — in line with the typical market range for similar vehicles · 3 days listed (based on current market benchmarks)
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2018 Toyota Camry
Madison, WI
Market: $12,875 – $22,779
Comparison: 48 similar vehicles
Fairly priced — in line with the typical market range for similar vehicles · 13 days listed (based on current market benchmarks)
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2010 Lexus RX
Madison, WI
Market: $4,990 – $16,408
Comparison: 46 similar vehicles
Fairly priced — in line with the typical market range for similar vehicles · 20 days listed (based on current market benchmarks)
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2023 Volkswagen ID.4
Madison, WI
Market: $23,374 – $27,100
Comparison: 42 similar vehicles
Fairly priced — in line with the typical market range for similar vehicles · 25 days listed (based on current market benchmarks)
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2021 Jeep Wrangler Unlimited
Madison, WI
Market: $18,317 – $29,271
Comparison: 39 similar vehicles
Fairly priced — in line with the typical market range for similar vehicles · 25 days listed (based on current market benchmarks)
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2015 Honda Pilot
Madison, WI
Market: $8,499 – $19,195
Comparison: 35 similar vehicles
Fairly priced — in line with the typical market range for similar vehicles · 2 days listed (based on current market benchmarks)
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2019 Cadillac XT5
Madison, WI
Market: $15,550 – $23,998
Comparison: 33 similar vehicles
Fairly priced — in line with the typical market range for similar vehicles · 11 days listed (based on current market benchmarks)
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2025 Toyota Sienna
Madison, WI
Market: $40,390 – $54,970
Comparison: 28 similar vehicles
Fairly priced — in line with the typical market range for similar vehicles · 25 days listed (based on current market benchmarks)
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2025 Toyota Corolla
Madison, WI
Market: $19,995 – $23,995
Comparison: 26 similar vehicles
Fairly priced — in line with the typical market range for similar vehicles · 4 days listed (based on current market benchmarks)
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2022 Toyota Tundra
Madison, WI
Market: $39,845 – $43,219
Comparison: 25 similar vehicles
Fairly priced — in line with the typical market range for similar vehicles · 25 days listed (based on current market benchmarks)
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2026 Toyota RAV4
Madison, WI
Market: $41,984 – $43,989
Comparison: 25 similar vehicles
Fairly priced — in line with the typical market range for similar vehicles · 25 days listed (based on current market benchmarks)
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2026 Toyota RAV4
Madison, WI
Market: $41,984 – $43,989
Comparison: 25 similar vehicles
Fairly priced — in line with the typical market range for similar vehicles · 5 days listed (based on current market benchmarks)
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2013 Toyota Tacoma
Madison, WI
Market: $11,868 – $29,850
Comparison: 23 similar vehicles
Fairly priced — in line with the typical market range for similar vehicles · 10 days listed (based on current market benchmarks)
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2019 Toyota Sequoia
Madison, WI
Market: $33,959 – $43,261
Comparison: 23 similar vehicles
Fairly priced — in line with the typical market range for similar vehicles · 25 days listed (based on current market benchmarks)
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2024 Toyota bZ4X
Madison, WI
Market: $23,492 – $30,309
Comparison: 22 similar vehicles
Fairly priced — in line with the typical market range for similar vehicles · 5 days listed (based on current market benchmarks)
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2025 Toyota RAV4
Madison, WI
Market: $31,494 – $36,032
Comparison: 22 similar vehicles
Fairly priced — in line with the typical market range for similar vehicles · 25 days listed (based on current market benchmarks)
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2018 Toyota Highlander
Madison, WI
Market: $19,990 – $27,300
Comparison: 21 similar vehicles
Fairly priced — in line with the typical market range for similar vehicles · 25 days listed (based on current market benchmarks)
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2024 Toyota Tacoma
Madison, WI
Market: $32,800 – $41,313
Comparison: 21 similar vehicles
Fairly priced — in line with the typical market range for similar vehicles · 9 days listed (based on current market benchmarks)
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2013 Toyota Camry
Madison, WI
Market: $4,644 – $14,995
Comparison: 20 similar vehicles
Fairly priced — in line with the typical market range for similar vehicles · 4 days listed (based on current market benchmarks)
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2024 Toyota Corolla
Madison, WI
Market: $18,992 – $21,055
Comparison: 20 similar vehicles
Fairly priced — in line with the typical market range for similar vehicles · 16 days listed (based on current market benchmarks)
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2017 Toyota Highlander
Madison, WI
Market: $15,950 – $29,590
Comparison: 19 similar vehicles
Fairly priced — in line with the typical market range for similar vehicles · 4 days listed (based on current market benchmarks)
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2026 Toyota Corolla
Madison, WI
Market: $27,221 – $32,279
Comparison: 19 similar vehicles
Fairly priced — in line with the typical market range for similar vehicles · 25 days listed (based on current market benchmarks)
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2014 Honda Civic
Madison, WI
Market: $8,250 – $15,406
Comparison: 17 similar vehicles
Fairly priced — in line with the typical market range for similar vehicles · 25 days listed (based on current market benchmarks)
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2023 Toyota RAV4
Madison, WI
Market: $34,940 – $38,386
Comparison: 16 similar vehicles
Fairly priced — in line with the typical market range for similar vehicles · 9 days listed (based on current market benchmarks)
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2024 Mazda CX-90
Madison, WI
Market: $25,390 – $28,495
Comparison: 15 similar vehicles
Fairly priced — in line with the typical market range for similar vehicles · 25 days listed (based on current market benchmarks)
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2023 Subaru Forester
Madison, WI
Market: $27,999 – $29,299
Comparison: 15 similar vehicles
Fairly priced — in line with the typical market range for similar vehicles · 25 days listed (based on current market benchmarks)
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2025 Toyota Camry
Madison, WI
Market: $27,311 – $40,358
Comparison: 14 similar vehicles
Fairly priced — in line with the typical market range for similar vehicles · 17 days listed (based on current market benchmarks)
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2012 Honda Accord
Madison, WI
Market: $5,376 – $14,990
Comparison: 13 similar vehicles
Fairly priced — in line with the typical market range for similar vehicles · 18 days listed (based on current market benchmarks)
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2023 Volkswagen Tiguan
Madison, WI
Market: $17,777 – $22,649
Comparison: 12 similar vehicles
Fairly priced — in line with the typical market range for similar vehicles · 4 days listed (based on current market benchmarks)
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2019 GMC Canyon
Madison, WI
Market: $17,544 – $24,565
Comparison: 12 similar vehicles
Fairly priced — in line with the typical market range for similar vehicles · 23 days listed (based on current market benchmarks)
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2026 Toyota C-HR
Madison, WI
Market: $37,393 – $39,998
Comparison: 11 similar vehicles
Fairly priced — in line with the typical market range for similar vehicles · 25 days listed (based on current market benchmarks)
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2026 Toyota RAV4
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2011 Toyota Sienna
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2014 Toyota Sienna
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2017 Honda Civic
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2013 Toyota Corolla
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2009 Acura MDX
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2006 Toyota Avalon
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2018 Kia Niro
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2018 Mazda CX-9
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2015 Toyota RAV4
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2013 Honda Civic
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2013 Scion xB
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2010 Lexus ES
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2019 Hyundai Elantra
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2014 Honda Accord
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2019 Volkswagen Tiguan
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2020 Subaru Ascent
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2013 Honda CR-V
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2016 Toyota RAV4
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2021 Nissan Armada
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2020 Honda HR-V
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2024 Mitsubishi Outlander
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2015 Lexus RC
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2013 Lexus ES
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2017 Acura TLX
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2018 Toyota 4Runner
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2017 Honda Ridgeline
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2021 Honda CR-V
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2024 Ford Maverick
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2021 Toyota Sienna
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2024 Toyota Venza
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2017 Audi TTS Coupe
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2026 Subaru Crosstrek
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2025 Toyota Corolla Cross
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2023 Toyota Camry
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2022 Toyota Highlander
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2025 Toyota RAV4
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2025 Toyota Corolla Cross
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2023 Toyota RAV4
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2024 Toyota RAV4
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2024 Toyota Highlander
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2023 Toyota RAV4
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2021 Toyota Sienna
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2022 Toyota RAV4
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2024 Toyota RAV4
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2020 Toyota RAV4
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2024 Toyota Tacoma
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2023 Toyota Highlander
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2024 Toyota Tacoma
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2023 Toyota Tacoma
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2024 Toyota Tacoma
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2026 Honda Odyssey
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2025 Subaru Forester
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2025 Audi New A5
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2022 Acura MDX
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2022 Lexus NX
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2026 Jeep Grand Cherokee
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2022 Toyota 4Runner
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2023 Toyota Tundra
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2023 Lexus IS
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2026 GMC Sierra 1500
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2025 Toyota Sienna
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2026 Volkswagen Golf R
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2024 Toyota Tundra
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Image from the dealer's site. OAV does not own, control, or store dealer images.
2026 Toyota Tacoma
Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Reviews & OAV Score™
Buyer reviews and the composite OAV Score™ for Gary Sells Cars inventory in Madison, WI.
not enough data yet
No published reviews yet.
How this dealer listing is verified
This dealer entry is one of 56,000+ U.S. dealerships tracked by OAV. Inventory counts and pricing statistics shown above are derived from the dealer's publicly advertised vehicle listings, aggregated and standardized using OAV's patented vehicle market standardization technology (U.S. Patent No. 12,236,477). Individual vehicle VINs in the listings above can be independently verified at the NHTSA VIN decoder.
This page renders OAV's public market summary for this rooftop. Dealers who want this listing removed entirely may email oavsupport@oav.io.