Best used sedans in Rochester, NY
used · sedans · in Rochester, NY · observed 2026-10-20
As of 2026-10-20, there are 525 used sedans in Rochester, NY. Median asking price $18,174. Best-supported: 2019 Nissan Altima SL at $11,788, a Great Deal — $1,211 below the comparable range (n=16).
Market snapshot
- Matching
- 525
- Median price
- $18,174
- Price range
- $4,599–$84,167
- Verdict-backed
- at least 93 of 525
Best-supported used deals
Ranked by Price-to-Market: grouped by verdict — Great Deal first, then Fair Price, then Overpriced — and within each group ordered by how far the asking price sits below the midpoint of its comparable range, then by price. Listings with a long time on lot or an implausible discount are demoted within their group and flagged for verification; high-mileage listings are shown separately.
- Miles:
- 101,693
- Below market:
- $1,211
- Comparables:
- n=16
- Days listed:
- 4
2019 Nissan Altima SL is $1,211 below the comparable range (n=16 comparables) — the strongest supported price-to-market value here.
- Miles:
- 7,626
- Below market:
- $2,421
- Comparables:
- n=16
- Days listed:
- 72
2026 Toyota Camry Nightshade is $2,421 below the comparable range (n=16 comparables). Near-new — evaluated against used comparables; new-car pricing may differ.
- Miles:
- 110,342
- Below market:
- $996
- Comparables:
- n=10
- Days listed:
- 179
2018 Chevrolet Cruze LT is $996 below the comparable range (n=10 comparables).
- Miles:
- 9,055
- Below market:
- $3,086
- Comparables:
- n=17
- Days listed:
- 8
2025 Subaru WRX Premium is $3,086 below the comparable range (n=17 comparables). Near-new — evaluated against used comparables; new-car pricing may differ.
- Miles:
- 13,244
- Below market:
- $1,370
- Comparables:
- n=11
- Days listed:
- 32
2023 Honda Accord LX is $1,370 below the comparable range (n=11 comparables).
- Miles:
- 14,369
- Below market:
- $1,740
- Comparables:
- n=11
- Days listed:
- 17
2024 Chevrolet Malibu 2LT is $1,740 below the comparable range (n=11 comparables).
- Miles:
- 36,438
- Below market:
- $1,095
- Comparables:
- n=18
- Days listed:
- 90
2023 INFINITI Q50 LUXE is $1,095 below the comparable range (n=18 comparables).
- Miles:
- 18,224
- Below market:
- $972
- Comparables:
- n=16
- Days listed:
- 6
2024 Honda Civic Sport is $972 below the comparable range (n=16 comparables).
- Miles:
- 64,046
- Below market:
- $1,602
- Comparables:
- n=22
- Days listed:
- 17
2019 Hyundai Sonata SE is $1,602 below the comparable range (n=22 comparables). ⚠ Verify — an unusually steep discount; this discount may not reflect real value.
- Miles:
- 81,078
- Comparables:
- n=10
- Days listed:
- 62
2019 Chevrolet Cruze LT: Fair Price at $11,995.
- Miles:
- 113,901
- Comparables:
- n=37
- Days listed:
- 132
2019 Toyota Corolla LE: Fair Price at $12,995.
- Miles:
- 59,374
- Comparables:
- n=67
- Days listed:
- 35
2025 Nissan Altima SV: Fair Price at $18,174.
- Miles:
- 53,720
- Comparables:
- n=11
- Days listed:
- 52
2024 Chevrolet Malibu 1LT: Fair Price at $17,674.
- Miles:
- 99,763
- Comparables:
- n=25
- Days listed:
- 69
2016 BMW 5 Series 528i: Fair Price at $11,995.
- Miles:
- 12,512
- Comparables:
- n=15
- Days listed:
- 48
2026 Toyota Camry LE: Fair Price at $29,998. Near-new — evaluated against used comparables; new-car pricing may differ.
- Miles:
- 8,803
- Comparables:
- n=12
- Days listed:
- 48
2026 Toyota Camry SE: Fair Price at $31,865. Near-new — evaluated against used comparables; new-car pricing may differ.
- Miles:
- 18,915
- Comparables:
- n=10
- Days listed:
- 37
2026 Toyota Corolla LE: Fair Price at $23,674.
- Miles:
- 91,603
- Comparables:
- n=11
- Days listed:
- 13
2017 Chevrolet Malibu 1LT: Fair Price at $9,995.
- Miles:
- 107,455
- Comparables:
- n=26
- Days listed:
- 179
2015 Nissan Altima SV: Fair Price at $6,499.
- Miles:
- 12,435
- Comparables:
- n=10
- Days listed:
- 39
2026 Toyota Corolla LE: Fair Price at $24,174. Near-new — evaluated against used comparables; new-car pricing may differ.
- Miles:
- 16,398
- Comparables:
- n=27
- Days listed:
- 5
2023 Hyundai Elantra SEL: Fair Price at $20,998.
- Miles:
- 118,718
- Comparables:
- n=43
- Days listed:
- 70
2014 Ford Focus SE: Fair Price at $4,999.
- Miles:
- 114,076
- Comparables:
- n=11
- Days listed:
- 38
2014 Chevrolet Impala 2LT: Fair Price at $8,998.
- Miles:
- 106,792
- Comparables:
- n=17
- Days listed:
- 31
2015 Chevrolet Cruze 1LT: Fair Price at $6,995.
- Miles:
- 58,653
- Comparables:
- n=31
- Days listed:
- 39
2024 Nissan Sentra SV: Fair Price at $17,174.
- Miles:
- 20,322
- Comparables:
- n=23
- Days listed:
- 30
2024 Honda Accord EX: Fair Price at $26,105.
- Miles:
- 97,366
- Comparables:
- n=31
- Days listed:
- 21
2016 Honda Civic LX: Fair Price at $12,495.
- Miles:
- 54,640
- Comparables:
- n=31
- Days listed:
- 132
2024 Nissan Sentra SV: Fair Price at $17,275.
- Miles:
- 30,663
- Comparables:
- n=44
- Days listed:
- 53
2024 Kia Forte GT-Line: Fair Price at $19,714.
- Miles:
- 39,602
- Comparables:
- n=22
- Days listed:
- 115
2023 Kia Forte GT-Line: Fair Price at $18,539.
- Miles:
- 50,702
- Comparables:
- n=14
- Days listed:
- 25
2025 Toyota Camry SE: Fair Price at $26,174.
- Miles:
- 12,047
- Comparables:
- n=11
- Days listed:
- 22
2024 Chevrolet Malibu 1LT: Fair Price at $22,170.
- Miles:
- 31,287
- Comparables:
- n=16
- Days listed:
- 72
2024 Honda Civic EX: Fair Price at $24,136.
- Miles:
- 55,128
- Comparables:
- n=28
- Days listed:
- 34
2024 Nissan Sentra SV: Fair Price at $17,568.
- Miles:
- 109,601
- Comparables:
- n=19
- Days listed:
- 165
2016 Chevrolet Cruze Limited 1LT: Fair Price at $7,250.
- Miles:
- 113,295
- Comparables:
- n=16
- Days listed:
- 54
2019 Nissan Altima SR: Fair Price at $13,104.
- Miles:
- 92,082
- Comparables:
- n=10
- Days listed:
- 56
2018 Honda Civic LX: Fair Price at $15,075.
- Miles:
- 11,564
- Comparables:
- n=46
- Days listed:
- 69
2024 Nissan Sentra SV: Fair Price at $19,215.
- Miles:
- 86,358
- Comparables:
- n=21
- Days listed:
- 77
2021 Nissan Altima SR: Fair Price at $14,995.
- Miles:
- 39,983
- Comparables:
- n=18
- Days listed:
- 18
2025 Honda Civic LX: Fair Price at $23,466.
- Miles:
- 33,517
- Comparables:
- n=11
- Days listed:
- 13
2021 Chevrolet Malibu RS: Fair Price at $18,500.
- Miles:
- 89,842
- Comparables:
- n=10
- Days listed:
- 10
2017 Lincoln MKZ Reserve: Fair Price at $12,990.
- Miles:
- 33,021
- Comparables:
- n=70
- Days listed:
- 48
2025 Toyota Corolla LE: Fair Price at $22,174.
- Miles:
- 19,167
- Comparables:
- n=13
- Days listed:
- 10
2024 Kia K5 GT-Line: Fair Price at $26,060.
- Miles:
- 33,997
- Comparables:
- n=16
- Days listed:
- 25
2025 Kia K4 LXS: Fair Price at $19,654.
- Miles:
- 100,358
- Comparables:
- n=24
- Days listed:
- 3
2016 Honda Civic EX: Fair Price at $13,995.
- Miles:
- 53,750
- Comparables:
- n=19
- Days listed:
- 9
2024 Nissan Sentra SV: Fair Price at $18,128.
- Miles:
- 83,617
- Comparables:
- n=19
- Days listed:
- 13
2015 Honda Accord LX: Fair Price at $12,995.
- Miles:
- 5,177
- Comparables:
- n=133
- Days listed:
- 91
2025 Nissan Sentra SV: Fair Price at $19,717. Near-new — evaluated against used comparables; new-car pricing may differ.
- Miles:
- 7,554
- Comparables:
- n=133
- Days listed:
- 69
2025 Nissan Sentra SV: Fair Price at $19,717. Near-new — evaluated against used comparables; new-car pricing may differ.
- Miles:
- 7,298
- Comparables:
- n=133
- Days listed:
- 33
2025 Nissan Sentra SV: Fair Price at $19,717. Near-new — evaluated against used comparables; new-car pricing may differ.
- Miles:
- 39,322
- Comparables:
- n=14
- Days listed:
- 16
2024 Kia Forte LXS: Fair Price at $18,499.
- Miles:
- 40,509
- Comparables:
- n=10
- Days listed:
- 3
2025 Toyota Camry SE: Fair Price at $27,996.
- Miles:
- 47,644
- Comparables:
- n=15
- Days listed:
- 53
2023 Honda Accord EX: Fair Price at $23,487.
- Miles:
- 28,857
- Comparables:
- n=11
- Days listed:
- 13
2025 Honda Accord SE: Fair Price at $26,998.
- Miles:
- 23,169
- Comparables:
- n=16
- Days listed:
- 24
2024 Honda Accord Hybrid Sport: Fair Price at $28,557.
- Miles:
- 29,951
- Comparables:
- n=72
- Days listed:
- 25
2023 Hyundai Elantra SEL: Fair Price at $20,108.
- Miles:
- 55,402
- Comparables:
- n=24
- Days listed:
- 56
2024 Honda Accord EX: Fair Price at $24,474.
- Miles:
- 47,018
- Comparables:
- n=20
- Days listed:
- 18
2024 Toyota Corolla LE: Fair Price at $20,167.
- Miles:
- 93,106
- Comparables:
- n=22
- Days listed:
- 32
2023 Nissan Altima SV: Fair Price at $17,995.
- Miles:
- 76,750
- Comparables:
- n=29
- Days listed:
- 15
2017 Mazda Mazda6 i Touring: Fair Price at $14,167.
- Miles:
- 70,107
- Comparables:
- n=10
- Days listed:
- 24
2017 Chevrolet Malibu 1LT: Fair Price at $12,400.
- Miles:
- 2,944
- Comparables:
- n=38
- Days listed:
- 9
2026 Honda Accord SE: Fair Price at $30,101. Near-new — evaluated against used comparables; new-car pricing may differ.
- Miles:
- 24,646
- Comparables:
- n=17
- Days listed:
- 54
2023 Kia Forte GT-Line: Fair Price at $19,825.
- Miles:
- 19,090
- Comparables:
- n=20
- Days listed:
- 27
2024 Honda Civic Sport: Fair Price at $26,890.
- Miles:
- 5
- Comparables:
- n=40
- Days listed:
- 103
2025 Hyundai Elantra Blue: Fair Price at $23,168. Near-new — evaluated against used comparables; new-car pricing may differ.
- Miles:
- 18,642
- Comparables:
- n=20
- Days listed:
- 6
2024 Honda Civic Sport: Fair Price at $26,900.
- Miles:
- 35,734
- Comparables:
- n=12
- Days listed:
- 27
2023 Toyota Corolla LE: Fair Price at $21,642.
- Miles:
- 103,351
- Comparables:
- n=34
- Days listed:
- 48
2016 Toyota Corolla LE: Fair Price at $14,413.
- Miles:
- 4,808
- Comparables:
- n=14
- Days listed:
- 18
2026 Honda Civic LX: Fair Price at $27,428. Near-new — evaluated against used comparables; new-car pricing may differ.
- Miles:
- 8,291
- Comparables:
- n=21
- Days listed:
- 5
2025 Toyota Corolla SE: Fair Price at $26,908. Near-new — evaluated against used comparables; new-car pricing may differ.
- Miles:
- 92,257
- Comparables:
- n=15
- Days listed:
- 4
2019 Subaru WRX Base: Fair Price at $18,998.
- Miles:
- 28,195
- Comparables:
- n=18
- Days listed:
- 18
2024 Honda Civic Sport: Fair Price at $26,054.
- Miles:
- 19,143
- Comparables:
- n=31
- Days listed:
- 13
2024 Honda Accord LX: Fair Price at $25,550.
- Miles:
- 29,427
- Comparables:
- n=23
- Days listed:
- 7
2024 Toyota Corolla SE: Fair Price at $25,529.
- Miles:
- 75,889
- Comparables:
- n=44
- Days listed:
- 34
2023 Honda Accord EX: Fair Price at $22,109.
- Miles:
- 99,200
- Comparables:
- n=23
- Days listed:
- 7
2018 Lexus ES 350: Fair Price at $21,998.
- Miles:
- 27,975
- Comparables:
- n=105
- Days listed:
- 52
2025 Toyota Corolla LE: Fair Price at $22,474.
- Miles:
- 113,000
- Comparables:
- n=15
- Days listed:
- 6
2011 BMW 3 Series 328i: Fair Price at $9,100.
- Miles:
- 95,608
- Comparables:
- n=10
- Days listed:
- 30
2014 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium: Fair Price at $7,990.
- Miles:
- 30,739
- Comparables:
- n=12
- Days listed:
- 60
2024 Honda Accord EX: Fair Price at $27,990.
- Miles:
- 26,048
- Comparables:
- n=33
- Days listed:
- 16
2023 Volkswagen Jetta SE: Fair Price at $20,890.
- Miles:
- 74,724
- Comparables:
- n=12
- Days listed:
- 18
2017 Honda Accord LX: Fair Price at $14,200.
- Miles:
- 68,433
- Comparables:
- n=23
- Days listed:
- 24
2020 Kia Optima LX: Fair Price at $15,998.
- Miles:
- 42,060
- Comparables:
- n=22
- Days listed:
- 21
2024 Subaru Legacy Limited: Fair Price at $25,375.
- Miles:
- 32,610
- Comparables:
- n=12
- Days listed:
- 53
2024 Honda Accord EX: Fair Price at $28,690.
- Miles:
- 19,780
- Comparables:
- n=15
- Days listed:
- 53
2024 Honda Accord EX: Fair Price at $30,190.
- Miles:
- 57,808
- Comparables:
- n=28
- Days listed:
- 31
2024 Nissan Sentra SV: Fair Price at $20,143.
- Miles:
- 34,634
- Comparables:
- n=12
- Days listed:
- 48
2024 Honda Accord EX: Fair Price at $28,990.
- Miles:
- 73,825
- Comparables:
- n=22
- Days listed:
- 73
2022 Dodge Charger SXT: Fair Price at $22,165.
- Miles:
- 92,244
- Comparables:
- n=20
- Days listed:
- 4
2018 Honda Accord LX: Fair Price at $15,995.
- Miles:
- 88,324
- Comparables:
- n=12
- Days listed:
- 60
2017 Toyota Camry SE: Fair Price at $17,431.
- Miles:
- 91,457
- Comparables:
- n=18
- Days listed:
- 224
2014 Dodge Avenger SE: Fair Price at $7,995. ⚠ Verify — 224 days listed; this discount may not reflect real value.
Other matching listings
These match your search but lacked enough comparables for an OAV price verdict — so they are not ranked as deals.
How OAV ranks these: used vehicles are ranked by price-to-market — how far each price sits below the comparable range for similar vehicles. Objective: best-supported deal. A verdict is shown only when enough comparables exist; otherwise the vehicle is left unscored, and anomalous listings are demoted and flagged for verification. OAV does not currently verify title status — confirm the title and a vehicle-history report before purchase.
Snapshot oav-2026-10-20-ny-rochester-used-sedan-any-collection-answer-v1 · methodology collection-answer-v1. Dealers may pay for analytics access, never for a verdict, ranking, or inclusion.