Best used trucks in Orchard Park, NY
used · trucks · in Orchard Park, NY · observed 2026-11-18
As of 2026-11-18, there are 316 used trucks in Orchard Park, NY. Median asking price $38,504. Best-supported: 2024 Ford F-350 Super Duty Lariat at $69,697, a Great Deal — $16,102 below the comparable range (n=27).
Market snapshot
- Matching
- 316
- Median price
- $38,504
- Price range
- $17,500–$92,500
- Verdict-backed
- at least 97 of 316
Best-supported used deals
Ranked by Price-to-Market: grouped by verdict — Great Deal first, then Fair Price, then Overpriced — and within each group ordered by how far the asking price sits below the midpoint of its comparable range, then by price. Listings with a long time on lot or an implausible discount are demoted within their group and flagged for verification; high-mileage listings are shown separately.
- Miles:
- 22,673
- Below market:
- $16,102
- Comparables:
- n=27
- Days listed:
- 17
2024 Ford F-350 Super Duty Lariat is $16,102 below the comparable range (n=27 comparables) — the strongest supported price-to-market value here.
- Miles:
- 49,612
- Below market:
- $4,517
- Comparables:
- n=12
- Days listed:
- 132
2023 RAM 1500 Classic Warlock is $4,517 below the comparable range (n=12 comparables).
- Miles:
- 59,151
- Below market:
- $2,031
- Comparables:
- n=44
- Days listed:
- 21
2022 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 RST is $2,031 below the comparable range (n=44 comparables).
- Miles:
- 100,851
- Below market:
- $703
- Comparables:
- n=26
- Days listed:
- 18
2019 RAM 1500 Pickup Big Horn/Lone Star is $703 below the comparable range (n=26 comparables).
- Miles:
- 43,689
- Below market:
- $1,579
- Comparables:
- n=18
- Days listed:
- 91
2023 Ford F-150 XLT is $1,579 below the comparable range (n=18 comparables).
- Miles:
- 26,686
- Below market:
- $2,184
- Comparables:
- n=28
- Days listed:
- 27
2023 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 LTZ is $2,184 below the comparable range (n=28 comparables).
- Miles:
- 58,736
- Below market:
- $2,692
- Comparables:
- n=22
- Days listed:
- 60
2021 Jeep Gladiator Sport S is $2,692 below the comparable range (n=22 comparables).
- Miles:
- 26,918
- Below market:
- $3,224
- Comparables:
- n=27
- Days listed:
- 48
2023 Ford Maverick XLT is $3,224 below the comparable range (n=27 comparables).
- Miles:
- 21,370
- Below market:
- $1,676
- Comparables:
- n=30
- Days listed:
- 46
2024 Ford F-150 Lariat is $1,676 below the comparable range (n=30 comparables).
- Miles:
- 51,650
- Below market:
- $2,754
- Comparables:
- n=27
- Days listed:
- 55
2023 Ford F-150 XL is $2,754 below the comparable range (n=27 comparables).
- Miles:
- 37,962
- Below market:
- $2,745
- Comparables:
- n=27
- Days listed:
- 73
2023 Ford Ranger XLT is $2,745 below the comparable range (n=27 comparables).
- Miles:
- 18,170
- Below market:
- $2,219
- Comparables:
- n=39
- Days listed:
- 46
2025 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 RST is $2,219 below the comparable range (n=39 comparables).
- Miles:
- 24,113
- Below market:
- $1,451
- Comparables:
- n=42
- Days listed:
- 10
2024 Ford F-150 STX is $1,451 below the comparable range (n=42 comparables).
- Miles:
- 59,533
- Below market:
- $1,134
- Comparables:
- n=30
- Days listed:
- 109
2023 Ford Ranger XLT is $1,134 below the comparable range (n=30 comparables).
- Miles:
- 21,039
- Below market:
- $1,899
- Comparables:
- n=27
- Days listed:
- 116
2023 Ford F-150 Raptor is $1,899 below the comparable range (n=27 comparables).
- Miles:
- 53,415
- Below market:
- $3,228
- Comparables:
- n=26
- Days listed:
- 183
2023 Nissan Frontier PRO-4X is $3,228 below the comparable range (n=26 comparables). ⚠ Verify — 183 days listed; this discount may not reflect real value.
- Miles:
- 101,223
- Comparables:
- n=13
- Days listed:
- 120
2020 Ford F-350 Super Duty Lariat: Fair Price at $38,174.
- Miles:
- 16,267
- Comparables:
- n=33
- Days listed:
- 110
2023 Ford F-150 XLT: Fair Price at $37,091.
- Miles:
- 103,889
- Comparables:
- n=17
- Days listed:
- 5
2019 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 LD LT Z71: Fair Price at $20,995.
- Miles:
- 20,470
- Comparables:
- n=29
- Days listed:
- 126
2024 Ford Ranger XLT: Fair Price at $34,095.
- Miles:
- 43,046
- Comparables:
- n=49
- Days listed:
- 54
2024 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 LT: Fair Price at $34,509.
- Miles:
- 56,415
- Comparables:
- n=30
- Days listed:
- 17
2021 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 Custom: Fair Price at $28,556.
- Miles:
- 74,657
- Comparables:
- n=100
- Days listed:
- 151
2020 RAM 1500 Classic Warlock: Fair Price at $21,349.
- Miles:
- 34,830
- Comparables:
- n=30
- Days listed:
- 68
2023 Ford F-150 XLT: Fair Price at $38,934.
- Miles:
- 65,298
- Comparables:
- n=113
- Days listed:
- 18
2024 Ford F-150 XLT: Fair Price at $35,140.
- Miles:
- 35,598
- Comparables:
- n=40
- Days listed:
- 99
2023 RAM 1500 Pickup Big Horn/Lone Star: Fair Price at $32,110.
- Miles:
- 4,332
- Comparables:
- n=36
- Days listed:
- 77
2025 Ford Ranger XLT: Fair Price at $38,704. Near-new — evaluated against used comparables; new-car pricing may differ.
- Miles:
- 28,671
- Comparables:
- n=16
- Days listed:
- 47
2025 Ford F-150 XLT: Fair Price at $36,994.
- Miles:
- 19,506
- Comparables:
- n=17
- Days listed:
- 11
2024 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 LT: Fair Price at $35,694.
- Miles:
- 15,597
- Comparables:
- n=23
- Days listed:
- 7
2025 Honda Ridgeline Black Edition: Fair Price at $37,496.
- Miles:
- 94,817
- Comparables:
- n=17
- Days listed:
- 68
2021 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 Custom: Fair Price at $27,119.
- Miles:
- 16,888
- Comparables:
- n=19
- Days listed:
- 84
2024 Ford Maverick Lariat: Fair Price at $31,824.
- Miles:
- 38,931
- Comparables:
- n=102
- Days listed:
- 32
2024 Nissan Frontier PRO-4X: Fair Price at $33,938.
- Miles:
- 39,488
- Comparables:
- n=20
- Days listed:
- 12
2023 RAM 1500 Pickup Big Horn/Lone Star: Fair Price at $32,739.
- Miles:
- 84,717
- Comparables:
- n=43
- Days listed:
- 5
2019 Toyota Tundra SR5: Fair Price at $35,997.
- Miles:
- 34,433
- Comparables:
- n=80
- Days listed:
- 47
2025 RAM 1500 Pickup Big Horn/Lone Star: Fair Price at $37,976.
- Miles:
- 24,620
- Comparables:
- n=37
- Days listed:
- 27
2025 Ford Maverick XLT: Fair Price at $29,995.
- Miles:
- 106,890
- Comparables:
- n=11
- Days listed:
- 15
2017 Ford F-150 XLT: Fair Price at $20,500.
- Miles:
- 8,790
- Comparables:
- n=27
- Days listed:
- 5
2024 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 LT: Fair Price at $37,283.
- Miles:
- 19,139
- Comparables:
- n=53
- Days listed:
- 6
2025 Chevrolet Colorado Trail Boss: Fair Price at $39,318.
- Miles:
- 48,185
- Comparables:
- n=27
- Days listed:
- 8
2022 Nissan Frontier PRO-4X: Fair Price at $31,748.
- Miles:
- 58,984
- Comparables:
- n=16
- Days listed:
- 20
2020 Ford F-150 XL: Fair Price at $27,996.
- Miles:
- 52,628
- Comparables:
- n=32
- Days listed:
- 62
2021 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 LT Trail Boss: Fair Price at $35,823.
- Miles:
- 32,740
- Comparables:
- n=39
- Days listed:
- 49
2023 RAM 1500 Pickup Big Horn/Lone Star: Fair Price at $33,932.
- Miles:
- 17,101
- Comparables:
- n=82
- Days listed:
- 34
2023 Ford F-150 XL: Fair Price at $38,567.
- Miles:
- 89,140
- Comparables:
- n=76
- Days listed:
- 46
2021 RAM 1500 Pickup Rebel: Fair Price at $33,989.
- Miles:
- 72,559
- Comparables:
- n=83
- Days listed:
- 130
2020 Ford F-150 Lariat: Fair Price at $31,772.
- Miles:
- 108,490
- Comparables:
- n=15
- Days listed:
- 50
2019 Honda Ridgeline RTL: Fair Price at $20,719.
- Miles:
- 34,773
- Comparables:
- n=33
- Days listed:
- 5
2024 Ford Maverick XLT: Fair Price at $28,500.
- Miles:
- 30,634
- Comparables:
- n=33
- Days listed:
- 80
2023 Honda Ridgeline RTL: Fair Price at $31,802.
- Miles:
- 45,582
- Comparables:
- n=14
- Days listed:
- 20
2022 Ford F-150 XLT: Fair Price at $37,995.
- Miles:
- 103,113
- Comparables:
- n=22
- Days listed:
- 21
2019 Ford F-150 Lariat: Fair Price at $27,493.
- Miles:
- 96,302
- Comparables:
- n=52
- Days listed:
- 17
2020 Ford F-150 XLT: Fair Price at $25,796.
- Miles:
- 47,477
- Comparables:
- n=15
- Days listed:
- 8
2022 Chevrolet Colorado Z71: Fair Price at $31,947.
- Miles:
- 66,008
- Comparables:
- n=37
- Days listed:
- 29
2021 Nissan Frontier SV: Fair Price at $22,966.
- Miles:
- 70,047
- Comparables:
- n=34
- Days listed:
- 90
2016 Ford F-150 XLT: Fair Price at $22,499.
- Miles:
- 34,294
- Comparables:
- n=14
- Days listed:
- 4
2024 Toyota Tacoma SR5: Fair Price at $35,500.
- Miles:
- 35,859
- Comparables:
- n=15
- Days listed:
- 18
2025 Ford F-150 XLT: Fair Price at $36,110.
- Miles:
- 66,232
- Comparables:
- n=64
- Days listed:
- 11
2021 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 LT: Fair Price at $28,141.
- Miles:
- 102,255
- Comparables:
- n=138
- Days listed:
- 50
2018 Ford F-150 XLT: Fair Price at $22,479.
- Miles:
- 49,424
- Comparables:
- n=60
- Days listed:
- 66
2022 RAM 1500 Classic Warlock: Fair Price at $28,749.
- Miles:
- 11,135
- Comparables:
- n=68
- Days listed:
- 27
2023 Ford F-150 XL: Fair Price at $39,411.
- Miles:
- 67,166
- Comparables:
- n=17
- Days listed:
- 81
2021 Jeep Gladiator WILLYS: Fair Price at $24,642.
- Miles:
- 62,890
- Comparables:
- n=28
- Days listed:
- 5
2021 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 LTZ: Fair Price at $33,962.
- Miles:
- 34,346
- Comparables:
- n=34
- Days listed:
- 15
2024 Chevrolet Colorado Trail Boss: Fair Price at $35,934.
- Miles:
- 37,557
- Comparables:
- n=13
- Days listed:
- 41
2023 Chevrolet Colorado LT: Fair Price at $32,537.
- Miles:
- 48,412
- Comparables:
- n=18
- Days listed:
- 154
2023 Ford F-150 XLT: Fair Price at $37,448.
- Miles:
- 65,726
- Comparables:
- n=97
- Days listed:
- 11
2020 Ford F-150 Lariat: Fair Price at $32,996.
- Miles:
- 61,693
- Comparables:
- n=33
- Days listed:
- 19
2022 Ford F-150 XL: Fair Price at $27,980.
- Miles:
- 50,804
- Comparables:
- n=39
- Days listed:
- 28
2022 Chevrolet Colorado Z71: Fair Price at $31,550.
- Miles:
- 72,395
- Comparables:
- n=40
- Days listed:
- 32
2022 Ford F-150 XL: Fair Price at $28,119.
- Miles:
- 12,924
- Comparables:
- n=32
- Days listed:
- 101
2024 Chevrolet Colorado LT: Fair Price at $34,913.
- Miles:
- 49,637
- Comparables:
- n=28
- Days listed:
- 5
2024 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 LT: Fair Price at $38,950.
- Miles:
- 72,656
- Comparables:
- n=34
- Days listed:
- 10
2022 Ford F-150 XL: Fair Price at $28,324.
- Miles:
- 76,799
- Comparables:
- n=26
- Days listed:
- 14
2019 RAM 1500 Pickup Big Horn/Lone Star: Fair Price at $26,324.
- Miles:
- 25,816
- Comparables:
- n=48
- Days listed:
- 3
2024 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 LT: Fair Price at $36,925.
- Miles:
- 77,431
- Comparables:
- n=23
- Days listed:
- 40
2019 RAM 1500 Classic Warlock: Fair Price at $24,300.
- Miles:
- 27,949
- Comparables:
- n=13
- Days listed:
- 49
2022 RAM 1500 Pickup Big Horn/Lone Star: Fair Price at $36,284.
- Miles:
- 75,509
- Comparables:
- n=26
- Days listed:
- 14
2021 Toyota Tacoma SR: Fair Price at $29,975.
- Miles:
- 77,848
- Comparables:
- n=13
- Days listed:
- 5
2021 GMC Sierra 1500 Elevation: Fair Price at $30,187.
- Miles:
- 17,780
- Comparables:
- n=34
- Days listed:
- 12
2024 Chevrolet Colorado LT: Fair Price at $35,917.
- Miles:
- 61,242
- Comparables:
- n=66
- Days listed:
- 13
2022 Toyota Tacoma TRD Off Road: Fair Price at $35,461.
- Miles:
- 86,408
- Comparables:
- n=77
- Days listed:
- 98
2023 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 Custom: Fair Price at $33,158.
- Miles:
- 87,950
- Comparables:
- n=117
- Days listed:
- 5
2018 Ford F-150 XLT: Fair Price at $24,787.
- Miles:
- 94,235
- Comparables:
- n=117
- Days listed:
- 7
2018 Ford F-150 XLT: Fair Price at $24,794.
- Miles:
- 40,675
- Comparables:
- n=87
- Days listed:
- 147
2023 Ford F-150 XL: Fair Price at $38,942.
- Miles:
- 71,310
- Comparables:
- n=45
- Days listed:
- 40
2020 GMC Sierra 1500 SLE: Fair Price at $28,971.
- Miles:
- 67,256
- Comparables:
- n=84
- Days listed:
- 15
2020 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 Custom: Fair Price at $30,667.
- Miles:
- 83,993
- Comparables:
- n=23
- Days listed:
- 6
2018 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 LT Z71: Fair Price at $25,758.
- Miles:
- 76,459
- Comparables:
- n=52
- Days listed:
- 50
2022 RAM 1500 Pickup Big Horn/Lone Star: Fair Price at $32,776.
- Miles:
- 61,560
- Comparables:
- n=53
- Days listed:
- 14
2021 Ford F-150 Lariat: Fair Price at $36,984.
- Miles:
- 106,116
- Comparables:
- n=20
- Days listed:
- 40
2016 Ford F-150 XLT: Fair Price at $27,700.
- Miles:
- 62,108
- Comparables:
- n=37
- Days listed:
- 15
2022 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 Limited LT Trail Boss: Fair Price at $36,165.
- Miles:
- 15,655
- Comparables:
- n=26
- Days listed:
- 194
2023 Ford F-150 XLT: Fair Price at $38,749. ⚠ Verify — 194 days listed; this discount may not reflect real value.
- Miles:
- 30,974
- Comparables:
- n=33
- Days listed:
- 190
2023 Honda Ridgeline RTL: Fair Price at $30,800. ⚠ Verify — 190 days listed; this discount may not reflect real value.
- Miles:
- 33,990
- Comparables:
- n=14
- Days listed:
- 190
2022 Ford F-150 XLT: Fair Price at $35,434. ⚠ Verify — 190 days listed; this discount may not reflect real value.
- Miles:
- 29,250
- Comparables:
- n=68
- Days listed:
- 215
2024 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 LT: Fair Price at $36,409. ⚠ Verify — 215 days listed; this discount may not reflect real value.
Other matching listings
These match your search but lacked enough comparables for an OAV price verdict — so they are not ranked as deals.
How OAV ranks these: used vehicles are ranked by price-to-market — how far each price sits below the comparable range for similar vehicles. Objective: best-supported deal. A verdict is shown only when enough comparables exist; otherwise the vehicle is left unscored, and anomalous listings are demoted and flagged for verification. OAV does not currently verify title status — confirm the title and a vehicle-history report before purchase.
Snapshot oav-2026-11-18-ny-orchard-park-used-truck-any-collection-answer-v1 · methodology collection-answer-v1. Dealers may pay for analytics access, never for a verdict, ranking, or inclusion.