Best used sedans in Orchard Park, NY
used · sedans · in Orchard Park, NY · observed 2026-11-18
As of 2026-11-18, there are 139 used sedans in Orchard Park, NY. Median asking price $23,504. Best-supported: 2023 Hyundai Elantra Limited at $20,409, a Great Deal — $2,510 below the comparable range (n=27).
Market snapshot
- Matching
- 139
- Median price
- $23,504
- Price range
- $11,999–$90,701
- Verdict-backed
- 59 of 139
Best-supported used deals
Ranked by Price-to-Market: grouped by verdict — Great Deal first, then Fair Price, then Overpriced — and within each group ordered by how far the asking price sits below the midpoint of its comparable range, then by price. Listings with a long time on lot or an implausible discount are demoted within their group and flagged for verification; high-mileage listings are shown separately.
- Miles:
- 19,036
- Below market:
- $2,510
- Comparables:
- n=27
- Days listed:
- 168
2023 Hyundai Elantra Limited is $2,510 below the comparable range (n=27 comparables) — the strongest supported price-to-market value here.
- Miles:
- 15,996
- Below market:
- $1,364
- Comparables:
- n=68
- Days listed:
- 67
2024 Honda Accord EX is $1,364 below the comparable range (n=68 comparables).
- Miles:
- 96,433
- Below market:
- $1,628
- Comparables:
- n=13
- Days listed:
- 32
2018 Volkswagen Passat SE is $1,628 below the comparable range (n=13 comparables).
- Miles:
- 3,883
- Comparables:
- n=46
- Days listed:
- 14
2026 Honda Civic Sport: Fair Price at $26,599. Near-new — evaluated against used comparables; new-car pricing may differ.
- Miles:
- 88,790
- Comparables:
- n=26
- Days listed:
- 87
2020 Toyota Avalon Limited: Fair Price at $23,824.
- Miles:
- 79,316
- Comparables:
- n=12
- Days listed:
- 73
2020 Ford Fusion SE: Fair Price at $12,824.
- Miles:
- 27,200
- Comparables:
- n=26
- Days listed:
- 42
2024 Honda Accord EX: Fair Price at $25,229.
- Miles:
- 8,074
- Comparables:
- n=54
- Days listed:
- 19
2026 Volkswagen Jetta Sport: Fair Price at $22,425. Near-new — evaluated against used comparables; new-car pricing may differ.
- Miles:
- 3,311
- Comparables:
- n=54
- Days listed:
- 19
2026 Volkswagen Jetta Sport: Fair Price at $22,495. Near-new — evaluated against used comparables; new-car pricing may differ.
- Miles:
- 4,037
- Comparables:
- n=38
- Days listed:
- 112
2026 Volkswagen Jetta SE: Fair Price at $23,995. Near-new — evaluated against used comparables; new-car pricing may differ.
- Miles:
- 20,466
- Comparables:
- n=21
- Days listed:
- 55
2024 Honda Civic Sport: Fair Price at $23,476.
- Miles:
- 19,908
- Comparables:
- n=48
- Days listed:
- 80
2024 Honda Accord LX: Fair Price at $23,804.
- Miles:
- 2,434
- Comparables:
- n=54
- Days listed:
- 20
2026 Volkswagen Jetta Sport: Fair Price at $22,625. Near-new — evaluated against used comparables; new-car pricing may differ.
- Miles:
- 15,075
- Comparables:
- n=10
- Days listed:
- 8
2026 BMW 3 Series 330i: Fair Price at $39,999.
- Miles:
- 32,202
- Comparables:
- n=21
- Days listed:
- 6
2024 Nissan Altima SV: Fair Price at $20,500.
- Miles:
- 5,856
- Comparables:
- n=13
- Days listed:
- 91
2026 Honda Accord SE: Fair Price at $28,702. Near-new — evaluated against used comparables; new-car pricing may differ.
- Miles:
- 27,286
- Comparables:
- n=16
- Days listed:
- 13
2024 Toyota Corolla LE: Fair Price at $22,725.
- Miles:
- 1,870
- Comparables:
- n=13
- Days listed:
- 80
2026 Hyundai Sonata SEL: Fair Price at $26,676. Near-new — evaluated against used comparables; new-car pricing may differ.
- Miles:
- 3,296
- Comparables:
- n=12
- Days listed:
- 97
2026 Hyundai Sonata SE: Fair Price at $24,995. Near-new — evaluated against used comparables; new-car pricing may differ.
- Miles:
- 13,945
- Comparables:
- n=12
- Days listed:
- 33
2024 Hyundai Elantra SEL: Fair Price at $20,890.
- Miles:
- 23,645
- Comparables:
- n=15
- Days listed:
- 22
2022 Honda Civic EX: Fair Price at $23,396.
- Miles:
- 22,756
- Comparables:
- n=59
- Days listed:
- 115
2024 Kia Forte GT-Line: Fair Price at $19,700.
- Miles:
- 28,338
- Comparables:
- n=21
- Days listed:
- 166
2024 Honda Civic Sport: Fair Price at $24,158.
- Miles:
- 61,455
- Comparables:
- n=21
- Days listed:
- 40
2024 Chevrolet Malibu 1LT: Fair Price at $16,896.
- Miles:
- 4,790
- Comparables:
- n=12
- Days listed:
- 11
2026 Hyundai Elantra SE: Fair Price at $22,379. Near-new — evaluated against used comparables; new-car pricing may differ.
- Miles:
- 28,396
- Comparables:
- n=22
- Days listed:
- 39
2024 Honda Accord EX: Fair Price at $26,309.
- Miles:
- 64,597
- Comparables:
- n=21
- Days listed:
- 36
2024 Chevrolet Malibu 1LT: Fair Price at $16,999.
- Miles:
- 14,414
- Comparables:
- n=12
- Days listed:
- 17
2024 Hyundai Elantra SEL: Fair Price at $21,089.
- Miles:
- 24,079
- Comparables:
- n=18
- Days listed:
- 123
2023 Kia Forte LXS: Fair Price at $17,599.
- Miles:
- 30,489
- Comparables:
- n=22
- Days listed:
- 56
2020 Hyundai Elantra Limited: Fair Price at $15,805.
- Miles:
- 920
- Comparables:
- n=46
- Days listed:
- 31
2024 Honda Civic Sport: Fair Price at $25,775.
- Miles:
- 69,636
- Comparables:
- n=23
- Days listed:
- 20
2021 Hyundai Elantra SEL: Fair Price at $15,144.
- Miles:
- 36,010
- Comparables:
- n=35
- Days listed:
- 42
2024 Honda Accord EX: Fair Price at $25,453.
- Miles:
- 2,010
- Comparables:
- n=12
- Days listed:
- 12
2026 Hyundai Elantra SE: Fair Price at $22,677. Near-new — evaluated against used comparables; new-car pricing may differ.
- Miles:
- 23,373
- Comparables:
- n=35
- Days listed:
- 20
2024 Nissan Sentra SV: Fair Price at $19,700.
- Miles:
- 21,624
- Comparables:
- n=13
- Days listed:
- 20
2024 Nissan Altima SV: Fair Price at $22,500.
- Miles:
- 28,649
- Comparables:
- n=17
- Days listed:
- 21
2024 Honda Civic Sport: Fair Price at $24,780.
- Miles:
- 1,341
- Comparables:
- n=13
- Days listed:
- 47
2026 Hyundai Sonata SEL: Fair Price at $27,619. Near-new — evaluated against used comparables; new-car pricing may differ.
- Miles:
- 20,901
- Comparables:
- n=46
- Days listed:
- 26
2023 Nissan Altima SV: Fair Price at $22,650.
- Miles:
- 42,219
- Comparables:
- n=14
- Days listed:
- 4
2024 Toyota Corolla LE: Fair Price at $22,777.
- Miles:
- 47,647
- Comparables:
- n=17
- Days listed:
- 42
2024 Nissan Altima SR: Fair Price at $21,984.
- Miles:
- 17,545
- Comparables:
- n=11
- Days listed:
- 35
2024 Mercedes-Benz C-Class Sedan C 300: Fair Price at $37,383.
- Miles:
- 12,894
- Comparables:
- n=13
- Days listed:
- 6
2024 Nissan Altima S: Fair Price at $20,712.
- Miles:
- 66,989
- Comparables:
- n=21
- Days listed:
- 76
2017 Volkswagen Jetta SE: Fair Price at $12,497.
- Miles:
- 10,169
- Comparables:
- n=42
- Days listed:
- 26
2024 Nissan Altima SV: Fair Price at $21,710.
- Miles:
- 17,821
- Comparables:
- n=27
- Days listed:
- 20
2025 Honda Accord SE: Fair Price at $27,723.
- Miles:
- 21,637
- Comparables:
- n=15
- Days listed:
- 49
2024 BMW 3 Series 330i: Fair Price at $36,921.
- Miles:
- 56,500
- Comparables:
- n=25
- Days listed:
- 21
2024 Toyota Camry SE: Fair Price at $27,756.
- Miles:
- 31,559
- Comparables:
- n=15
- Days listed:
- 43
2024 Honda Accord LX: Overpriced at $24,558.
- Miles:
- 3,451
- Comparables:
- n=12
- Days listed:
- 91
2026 Hyundai Sonata SE: Overpriced at $25,738. Near-new — evaluated against used comparables; new-car pricing may differ.
- Miles:
- 39,385
- Comparables:
- n=17
- Days listed:
- 19
2024 Toyota Corolla LE: Overpriced at $21,539.
- Miles:
- 35,932
- Comparables:
- n=28
- Days listed:
- 8
2024 Honda Civic Touring: Overpriced at $26,935.
- Miles:
- 8,730
- Comparables:
- n=26
- Days listed:
- 77
2026 Cadillac CT5 Premium Luxury: Overpriced at $51,723. Near-new — evaluated against used comparables; new-car pricing may differ.
- Miles:
- 1,576
- Comparables:
- n=13
- Days listed:
- 47
2026 Hyundai Sonata SEL: Overpriced at $28,071. Near-new — evaluated against used comparables; new-car pricing may differ.
- Miles:
- 45,273
- Comparables:
- n=11
- Days listed:
- 36
2024 Toyota Camry LE: Overpriced at $26,699.
- Miles:
- 15,551
- Comparables:
- n=34
- Days listed:
- 39
2024 Subaru WRX Premium: Overpriced at $31,455.
- Miles:
- 44,339
- Comparables:
- n=11
- Days listed:
- 95
2021 Volkswagen Jetta S: Overpriced at $17,169.
- Miles:
- 64,694
- Comparables:
- n=30
- Days listed:
- 39
2023 Kia Forte GT: Overpriced at $19,564.
- Miles:
- 22,944
- Comparables:
- n=17
- Days listed:
- 56
2024 Toyota Camry LE: Overpriced at $28,999.
Other matching listings
These match your search but lacked enough comparables for an OAV price verdict — so they are not ranked as deals.
How OAV ranks these: used vehicles are ranked by price-to-market — how far each price sits below the comparable range for similar vehicles. Objective: best-supported deal. A verdict is shown only when enough comparables exist; otherwise the vehicle is left unscored, and anomalous listings are demoted and flagged for verification. OAV does not currently verify title status — confirm the title and a vehicle-history report before purchase.
Snapshot oav-2026-11-18-ny-orchard-park-used-sedan-any-collection-answer-v1 · methodology collection-answer-v1. Dealers may pay for analytics access, never for a verdict, ranking, or inclusion.